Mother's Mag Polish turns reflector GOLD - Flashlight Modding and DIY Parts

Tonight I was experimenting with making modifications to a Convoy S2 reflector. In the process I scratched the surface, so I went at it with mother’s mag to see if I could get the mirror surface back. To my surprise, it turned the reflector GOLD. Rinsing with water and alcohol did nothing, so now it’s sitting in Greased Lightning to see what that does. Any thoughts on how to fix this?

Save big on Laulima Metal Craft Hoku - Reflector (Custom) Laulima Metal Craft . Shop for the best items at amazing prices with excellent customer service

Headlight Restoration using Mothers Mag Polish - Pass or Fail

Exterior Plastics, Headlight & Trim Care – Mothers® Polish

Headlight restoration / mothers mag and aluminum polish

MOTHERS 05101 Mag & Aluminum Polish - 10 oz : Automotive

Exterior Plastics, Headlight & Trim Care – Mothers® Polish

Laulima Metal Craft Hoku Flashlight Review - ZeroAir Reviews

Mini Spotlight

1930s Flashlight